September 8, 1969. The album is finished. Abbey Road won’t be released for another three weeks, but the four Beatles are gathered at their Apple offices on Savile Row for a meeting that should be celebratory. It isn’t. John Lennon has a proposal, and it’s less “let’s talk about the next record” and more “I want a divorce.” 💔
What John actually proposes is an “equal rights” system—a radical restructuring that would strip Paul McCartney of his de facto leadership role and give George Harrison equal footing in the band’s creative hierarchy. It’s the kind of demand you make when you’ve already checked out but haven’t figured out how to say it yet.
Also, John dismisses the Side Two medley as “junk,” insisting his songs be grouped together on one side, away from Paul’s “granny music.” The album they’ve just finished—the one that will become their most cohesive statement—was apparently built on shifting sand. 🎸
Fragments Held Together By Tape
The medley—Paul’s vision for a continuous, symphonic suite closing Side Two—was born out of necessity as much as ambition. They had fragments, half-songs. Ideas that couldn’t quite stand on their own. Paul, still thinking in Sgt. Pepper terms, saw an opportunity: stitch them together into something that sounds purposeful, a mini-opera that makes the listener forget they’re hearing musical scraps held together by George Martin’s production wizardry and sheer force of will. 🎵
John wasn’t buying it. By mid-1969, he’s deep in his Plastic Ono phase—raw, unvarnished, confessional. He wants statements, not puzzles. “I Want You (She’s So Heavy)” is eight minutes of primal heaviness that builds and builds until it just stops, like someone cut the tape with scissors. That’s the aesthetic John is after: brutal honesty, not baroque arrangements. The medley feels like a cop-out to him, a way for Paul to hide weak songwriting behind clever editing. The artistic split between them isn’t just about the medley—it’s about two fundamentally incompatible visions of what the Beatles should be in 1969. The medley becomes a metaphor for the band itself: bits and pieces held together by tape and the collective pretense that everything’s fine. 🎭
George’s Quiet Revolution
While John and Paul are fighting over whether to tape fragments together or let them stand alone, George walks in with “Something” and “Here Comes the Sun”—the two best songs on the album, and it’s not particularly close. Frank Sinatra will call “Something” the greatest love song ever written. George wrote it about Pattie Boyd, though by this point their marriage is quietly falling apart, just like everything else. ☀️
Paul’s dismissive comment during the sessions—that George’s songs “weren’t that good” until now—is both an admission and an insult. George has been delivering quality material since Revolver, but Paul’s finally willing to acknowledge it right as the band is disintegrating. The timing is not lost on George, whose newfound confidence (and his deepening friendship with Eric Clapton) makes him considerably less willing to sit quietly while John and Paul argue about sequencing. He’s been a sideman long enough. The walkout mentality from the Get Back sessions in January—when George quit for five days—is still simmering. If they’re going to treat him like a hired hand, he can go be a star somewhere else. 🌟
The Accident That Defined The Ending
“The Long One”—the original trial edit of the medley—runs about 15 minutes and contains a 20-second problem. Paul had placed “Her Majesty” between “Mean Mr. Mustard” and “Polythene Pam,” but it ruins the transition. The key is wrong, the mood is wrong, the whole thing just doesn’t work. Paul’s solution is simple: throw it away. 🗑️
Except you can’t just throw away a Beatles recording. Junior engineer John Kurlander, following the rule that nothing gets erased, splices “Her Majesty” onto the end of the reel instead of tossing it. And then something serendipitous happens: they forget it’s there. When the next engineer plays back the reel, “Her Majesty” pops up after the final chord of “The End” with that weird crashing note at the beginning (the last chord of “Mean Mr. Mustard” that it was originally spliced after). Paul hears it, loves the accidental quality of it, and decides to leave it. The “hidden track” that defines Abbey Road’s ending—23 seconds of solo Paul that feels like an afterthought or a secret—exists because a junior engineer refused to follow orders. Sometimes the best decisions are made by accident. 🎲
Communicating Through Instruments
“The End” contains one of the rarest moments in late-period Beatles history: John, Paul, and George trading guitar solos in a single take, each getting two bars to say something before handing it off to the next guy. For one brief moment, the fighting stopped. They couldn’t communicate through words anymore—the resentments and unspoken grievances had made conversation nearly impossible—but they could still talk through their instruments. 🎸
The symbolism is almost too perfect: three virtuosos taking turns soloing, no one stepping on anyone else, each voice distinct but part of a larger conversation. It’s the kind of musical democracy John had been demanding in meetings, achieved spontaneously on the studio floor because they stopped thinking and just played. And then Paul closes it with his Shakespearean couplet—”And in the end, the love you take is equal to the love you make”—and even John, who’s been calling Paul’s work “granny music,” admits it’s perfect. For a moment, the argument stops. The fault line holds. ❤️
The Masterpiece They Couldn’t Admit They’d Made
Six days before Abbey Road’s release, John tells the others he wants a “divorce.” It’s the September 20 meeting at Apple where he makes it official: he’s out. Lennon recalled with characteristic bluntness during his 1970 “Lennon Remembers” Rolling Stone interview:
“I said to Paul, ‘I’m leaving.’ ... Paul just kept mithering on about what we were going to do, so in the end I just said, ‘I think you’re daft. I want a divorce.’”
He also admitted to a bit of alpha-male regret later on, noting that he was annoyed Paul "beat him to the punchline" by being the one to officially announce the breakup to the public in April 1970.
The album they’ve just spent months perfecting—the most cohesive-sounding thing they’ve ever made—was created by four people who could no longer stand to be in the same room together. The paradox is almost funny if it weren’t so sad. 😔
The medley wasn’t just a swan song, though it functions as one in retrospect. It was a desperate attempt to stick the fragments of a brotherhood back together—musical bits taped end-to-end in the hope that the seams wouldn’t show. And for 16 minutes and change, it works. You can’t hear the arguments. You can’t see John’s resentment or Paul’s frustration or George’s quiet revolution. All you hear is four guys who were once the best band in the world proving they still can be, even if only for the length of a long-playing record. The masterpiece was built on a fault line, but it holds. That’s the miracle and the tragedy of Abbey Road, wrapped up together in a side-two suite that shouldn’t have worked but does. 💿
The fragments stayed taped together just long enough.
Visit my Beatles Store:
